BVIPirate Forum Index
Click for Beef Island, British Virgin Islands Forecast
Search FAQ
Log in Register
BVI Weather
Aristocat II No Longer in Charter Service with Pro Valor
Goto page Previous  1, 2, All  
Jump to:  
Post new topic   Reply to topic    BVIPirate Forum Index -> British Virgin Islands -> Charter Boats
View previous topic :: View next topic  
Author Message
DawnB
Link to this postPosted: Thu Nov 27, 2008 11:51 am    

saildoggie wrote:
So Dawn, are you aboard S/V Sanctuary?


Nope...I'm a monohuller... Laughing

Even with my recent experience aboard Jeannius, I still like sailing monohulls.

I'll be aboard a Bene 321 named Second Wind. There is just the two of us, so it is plenty big enough.
Back to top
MrBombastic
Link to this postPosted: Thu Nov 27, 2008 11:54 am    

saildoggie wrote:


I really hope they can work this out, any further spectulation is, well....speculation
confused


I would speculate that your speculating that speculative remarks have been made and future posts would be speculative. Is my speculation that you are speculating speculative or true? I would speculate that you believe my speculation is not speculative, but of course that would be speculative on my part.laugh
Back to top
saildoggie
Link to this postPosted: Thu Nov 27, 2008 12:55 pm    

MrBombastic wrote:
saildoggie wrote:


I really hope they can work this out, any further spectulation is, well....speculation
confused


I would speculate that your speculating that speculative remarks have been made and future posts would be speculative. Is my speculation that you are speculating speculative or true? I would speculate that you believe my speculation is not speculative, but of course that would be speculative on my part.laugh


confused confused confused Been hittin' that Holiday "Cheer' already? confused confused
Back to top
saildoggie
Link to this postPosted: Thu Nov 27, 2008 12:58 pm    

Dawn, I did not see Second Wind when we were at Pro Valor, prbably out on charter but wow, what a deal!

If we visit as just the Admiral and I that would be the way to go for sure!
Back to top
MrBombastic
Link to this postPosted: Thu Nov 27, 2008 1:47 pm    

saildoggie wrote:


confused confused confused Been hittin' that Holiday "Cheer' already? confused confused


Now, now, I couldn't write that if I was drunk. That's unfounded speculation on your part.
Back to top
DawnB
Link to this postPosted: Thu Nov 27, 2008 4:19 pm    

saildoggie wrote:
Dawn, I did not see Second Wind when we were at Pro Valor, prbably out on charter but wow, what a deal!

If we visit as just the Admiral and I that would be the way to go for sure!


Yup...a great deal. And from talking with Brent over the past few months, I don't think it is "too good to be true", but we'll see...

Are you down in the Islands before June, Saildoggie?
Back to top
kentth
Link to this postPosted: Thu Nov 27, 2008 10:50 pm    

I have Sanctuary chartered the first week of June. Hearing things like this doesn't make you feel too comfortable. So I sent an email to Tom Garvey the owner of Sanctuary. He reassured me that everything was fine and that there was more to the story. Which is what I figured.

You might want to get all sides of the story, before jumping to conclusions.

Kent
Back to top
MrBombastic
Link to this postPosted: Fri Nov 28, 2008 1:01 am    

kentth wrote:

You might want to get all sides of the story, before jumping to conclusions.

Kent


Well that's difficult if apparently the people that know all sides of the story don't want to tell it. confused confused
Back to top
Kerry
Link to this postPosted: Fri Nov 28, 2008 8:38 am    

Am I reading Pro Valor (Brents) site correct that he has only 3 boats available for charter? I am not sure that makes too profitable of a business...
Back to top
CaptJim
Link to this postPosted: Fri Nov 28, 2008 9:03 am    

Actually, I think Brent is down to two boats now.
Back to top
Guest
Link to this postPosted: Fri Nov 28, 2008 12:48 pm    

I want to preface my comments with two caveats:

1) I have a vested interest in this issue as the owner of Sanctuary;
2) This matter is currently the subject of a lawsuit filed in the BVIs by Brent against the Eads for breach of contract, so since I don't want to get involved in that I will be careful about what I say.

First of all, it is very unfortunate that we are discussing something like this in a forum that should be about sailing and having a good time, and I wish that no one had brought it up in a public forum, either on TTOL or here. But, given that it has been discussed, I will weigh in-

From what I know, this is a contract dispute between the Eads & Provalor/Brent. For the Eads to try to make it sound like it is related to maintenance issues is a red herring. There may be maintenance issues, I'm not going to comment one way or the other on that, but the maintenance issues cited are from within the last few months, and this all started several months ago.

What are facts are that the Eads had a contract to have their boat in charter with Brent, Brent had booked charters on the boat, the Eads wanted to make modifications in the contract that Brent wouldn't agree to, and the Eads pulled the boat with no notice and just a couple of days before a charterer was going to arrive to get on the boat. The charter was moved to Sanctuary, so Chuck & his crew were accomodated.

What is also a fact is that Brent has filed suit against the Eads and that, as the first action in that lawsuit, yesterday the boat was "arrested" by the BVI authorities, towed to Nanny Cay, hauled out and impounded. I can only assume that the authorities must have seen enough merit in Brent's lawsuit to take such an action.

Brent has refrained from disparaging the Eads in a public forum and in my view is acting as any business person would under the circumstances to protect his interests. So far, it looks like the law is on his side. Whatever the Eads' justifications may be in their own minds, they have seen fit to publicly disparage Brent on what is at best a secondary issue, which is tacky if not downright dishonest, and have acted in a way that led to their boat being impounded.

I will refrain from further comment on all this stuff unless I see someone posting something that I know with certainty to be untrue. I hope everyone else can also refrain from engaging in uninformed speculation and we can all get back to discussing fun stuff.

Cheers,
Tom
Back to top
Utopia
Link to this postPosted: Fri Nov 28, 2008 5:29 pm    

Tom,
Im not sure where you heard that from but some of your information is very untrue. Yes, we did want to renegoiate the original contract with Brent due to wanting more owner time. A few months ago we agreed upon an amendment to the original contract for additional owner time. At that time we were happy with the terms. That was the end of our contract issues.
When we arrived in October we were very unpleased with the condition of our boat. We spent 3 weeks thinking about this while we repaired and replaced problems on the boat. It was not an easy decision. We are aware that we have a contract with Brent, but feel that he breached that contract when he did not live up to the maintenance that was promised. We have to look out for our investment.
We have not said anything that is untrue and we are not trying to disparage Brent. We are simply telling our side of the story since an untrue version was posted. We have not made any statements up until we saw untrue information being written about us and would have preferred this be left off the forums as well.
The boat has been arrested simply because it is involved in a lawsuit and has nothing to do with authoritiies seeing merit in either side.
Back to top
saildoggie
Link to this postPosted: Fri Nov 28, 2008 8:14 pm    

After having a great time with Tony and Melody at the Cat Fight and also meeting Brent for the first time a few weeks ago.....

Me thinks we best leave this one alone here. Rolling Eyes




Back to top
kentth
Link to this postPosted: Fri Nov 28, 2008 10:38 pm    

2 boats, 3 boats or 200 boats...the size of the operation doesn't matter. just as long as you receive the product and service that you pay for. In fact most of the time you receive more bang for your buck from a smaller operation then a larger one. They generally bend over backwards to accommodate you and are actually interested in you as a customer and not just another account number.

Before we put our money down with any company, large or small, we check them out. large companies go bankrupt sometimes quicker then small ones. Before we signed our contract with Brent, I did a lot of checking into his company, I talked to past charters, checked into past history, etc. Of course I did the same thing before we chartered with Sunsail. Like Tom said we are all in this for the fun and a chance to get away from the daily grind.

I understand why Brent can not say anything if he has a pending lawsuit, so lets let them fight that out in court, but it is great to have forums like these for people to post both the good and the bad experience that they have and hopefully everybody can sort out the BS.

After sending my emails and doing my checks, my biggest hope is that when I get off the ferry in Roadtown that I have the boat that I paid for, so my family can enjoy their vacation, which I feel confident will occur.

Oh ah, I am a little partial to small companies, I run a company that daily goes to battle against a giant, they are 9500 times larger then me in sales volume and we kick their ass on a daily basis. They are down 16% on the year and we are only down 5%, not bad in an economy like we have now. There profits are down and mine are way up.

So back to the work, I have another of my competition's customers in my sights duel to take over next week. Heck I have to make more money so I can charter more boats.

Kent
Back to top
Display posts from previous:   
Post new topic   Reply to topic    BVIPirate Forum Index -> British Virgin Islands -> Charter Boats All times are CST (GMT - 6 Hours)
Goto page Previous  1, 2, All
Page 2 of 2
 
Jump to:  

Terms of Use